Skip to main content
Official Portal| Double-blind Peer Review · Open Access · Crossref DOIs

Author Guidelines

Before entering the submission system, we recommend that you use this page to prepare your manuscript and supporting files, check formatting and confirm your ethics declarations, and to understand editorial screening, peer review, open access licensing and the final checks required before submission.

Preparing Your Submission

  • Before submitting, please confirm that the subject scope, article types, calls for papers and first-round review time of your target journal match your research plan.
  • Please ensure that you have obtained permission to publish all materials in the manuscript (including photographs, documents and datasets) and that all listed authors have agreed to be named. Research involving human participants or animals must have obtained ethical approval in accordance with applicable laws.
  • Before submitting, check that your research design and argumentation are clear and complete, that the title is concise, and that the abstract can be read on its own. Manuscripts that do not meet basic quality standards may be rejected at the editorial screening stage.
  • We recommend preparing the title, abstract, keywords, author information, funding details, contact details and Chinese-language metadata in advance, to reduce duplicate data entry once you are in the submission system.

Files and Declarations

Template and main manuscript: please prepare and submit an editable main manuscript file using the target journal's template, together with any figures, images, supplementary materials or data attachments required. File names should be clear and stable so that the editorial office and reviewers can verify versions.

Similarity and AIGC reports: please prepare the full-text similarity report (similarity below 25%) and the full-text AIGC report (AI-generated content rate below 20%) as required, so that the editorial office can complete its basic compliance checks.

Raw data and supplementary materials: for empirical, interview-based and other manuscripts involving data analysis, please also prepare the raw research data and any necessary supplementary notes. If sharing is restricted, please explain the access limits, how the data are stored and the conditions under which they can be verified.

Permissions, authorship and ethics documents: if the manuscript uses third-party photographs, figures, documents or data, please submit the corresponding permissions. All listed authors must confirm the order of authorship and contribution details. Research involving human participants or animals should include ethical approval information or an exemption statement.

Originality and conflict of interest statements: authors should confirm that the manuscript has not been submitted elsewhere simultaneously and that citations, images, data sources and collaborations are fully disclosed. Any funding, collaboration or commercial relationships should be declared at submission.

Editorial Screening and Peer Review

The main website is for browsing journals, reading policies and accessing the submission portal. Formal submission, file upload, receipt of review comments and acceptance notices are all handled in the submission system. Authors should rely on the statuses, timestamps and email notifications shown in the system.

Review times vary with the discipline, the complexity of the manuscript, how quickly reviewers confirm and the number of revision rounds. The first-round review time shown on a journal's page is for reference only. The editorial office may, where necessary, request additional materials, format changes or updated declaration files.

Initial screening: after submission, the editorial office first checks that files and information are complete and that the manuscript fits the journal's scope and focus. Manuscripts that do not meet basic requirements are usually returned promptly with an explanation.

Format check and content assessment: the editorial office checks formatting requirements such as fonts, font sizes and heading levels, and assesses the manuscript's scholarly value, originality and relevance. Authors of manuscripts that do not meet the requirements are, as a rule, notified within one week and given specific suggestions for improvement.

Double-blind peer review: manuscripts that pass screening enter double-blind review, which protects the privacy of authors and reviewers and helps keep the process fair and objective. Standard manuscripts are usually reviewed by one to three experts; interdisciplinary or contentious manuscripts may be assigned three to four reviewers.

Revision requests and editorial decision: based on the review reports, the editorial office will decide whether to accept the manuscript, reject it or request revisions, and will give the authors specific, actionable revision comments. Authors should rely on the statuses, timestamps and email notifications shown in the system.

Reviewer Selection and Support

Reviewers are matched from the reviewer pool according to the manuscript's topic and research area. Priority is given to experts with reviewing experience, a good scholarly reputation and a closely matching research area, and the reviewer pool is updated regularly to maintain review quality and coverage.

Number of reviewers: each manuscript is usually reviewed by one to three experts. For interdisciplinary or contentious manuscripts, this may be increased to three to four reviewers in order to obtain more comprehensive feedback.

Selection principles and confidentiality: reviewers are selected by the editorial office on the basis of the manuscript's topic, research area and the experts' specialisms, and conduct their reviews under the double-blind system to ensure expertise, authority and confidentiality.

Recognition and benefits: reviewing can be recorded as a scholarly contribution in a reviewer's academic profile. Journals may publish lists of reviewers and award certificates to outstanding reviewers each year. High-quality reviewers may receive fast-track or priority consideration for their own future submissions, as well as journal subscription discounts and invitations to academic events.

Training and resources: the editorial office regularly organizes reviewer training and provides resources such as reviewer guidelines and answers to frequently asked questions, helping reviewers complete their reviews more efficiently and to a consistent standard.

Open Access Licensing and Distribution Rights

Works published in this journal are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). Once a manuscript enters the publication workflow, authors are expected to cooperate in confirming the open access license and permission documents; the requirements follow the OA policy, the licensing statement and system prompts.

Sharing and adaptation: under CC BY 4.0, readers and institutions may copy and redistribute the work in any medium or format, and may remix, transform and build upon it for any purpose.

Attribution and limits: when using the work, users must give appropriate credit to the authors and the source, provide a link to the license, and indicate whether changes were made to the original. They may not apply additional legal terms or technological measures that restrict others from using the work under this license.

Publisher's non-exclusive distribution right: authors grant the publishing body of the journal a worldwide, non-exclusive, royalty-free right of distribution, including print publication, distribution through the official website, databases and other online platforms, and long-term preservation, archiving and metadata management to support scholarly citation and access.

Final Checks Before Submission

  • Confirm that the target journal, article type and call for papers match your research, and that the title, abstract, keywords, order of authors and affiliations are consistent with the final version.
  • Confirm that the main manuscript has been prepared according to the template, and that all figures, tables, citations, appendices, supplementary materials and file names correspond correctly within the manuscript.
  • Confirm that the full-text similarity report (similarity below 25%), the full-text AIGC report (AI-generated content rate below 20%), and any necessary raw data or supplementary notes are complete.
  • Confirm that statements on originality, conflicts of interest, ethical approval, authorship, data availability and permissions for third-party materials are complete.
  • For information on APCs, payment and invoicing, please consult the Fees and Invoicing Guide before submitting. For further information on licensing and distribution boundaries, please also see the OA policy and the licensing statement.