Skip to main content
Official Portal| Double-blind Peer Review · Open Access · Crossref DOIs

Publication Ethics and Research Integrity

Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing follows the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) and national research integrity standards. We firmly oppose all forms of academic misconduct in order to safeguard the integrity of research and of the publishing record.

General Principles of Publication Ethics

Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing is guided by the principles of seeking truth, putting scholarship into practice, and open access for all. We strictly follow the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) and applicable national standards on research integrity.

We are committed to upholding the authenticity and seriousness of research and fairness in publishing. We firmly oppose all forms of academic misconduct and strive to provide researchers worldwide with a rigorous, transparent environment for scholarly exchange and publication.

Author Responsibilities and Ethical Standards

Authors submitting to journals published by Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing must adhere to the following principles of research integrity:

  • Originality and no plagiarism: submitted work must be the original research of the author team. Plagiarism of text, appropriation of ideas, misuse of experimental data and use of figures or tables without permission are strictly prohibited.
  • No simultaneous submission or duplicate publication: a manuscript must not be submitted to more than one publication at the same time, and work already formally published in another journal or in conference proceedings must not be resubmitted. "Salami slicing" of a single study into multiple publications is also subject to strict scrutiny.
  • Data authenticity and verifiability: authors must ensure that all experimental data, survey questionnaires, statistical samples and source materials are genuine and reliable. Fabrication, falsification or manipulation of data, and fabricated references, are strictly prohibited.
  • Proper authorship and contributor agreement: only those who have made substantive contributions to the design, execution, data analysis or writing of the study may be listed as authors. Buying or selling papers, ghostwriting and any form of honorary authorship ("gift authorship" or "guest authorship") are prohibited. The corresponding author must ensure that all listed authors have reviewed and approved the final manuscript and have agreed in writing on the order of authorship and on submission for publication.
  • Disclosure of conflicts of interest: authors must state all sources of funding at the end of the manuscript and honestly disclose any financial, commercial or personal relationships that could affect the objectivity or impartiality of the research.

Ethical Standards for Reviewers

As gatekeepers of scholarly quality and integrity, reviewers are expected to fulfill the following ethical obligations:

  • Objectivity and fairness: reviewers should write constructive, objective, evidence-based reports and must not show bias on the basis of an author's nationality, institutional rank, title or position, age, gender or school of thought.
  • Confidentiality and respect for intellectual property: during the review, reviewers must not circulate, retain or show unpublished manuscripts to others, and must not use an author's unpublished ideas, experimental designs or data in their own research.
  • No improper advantage: reviewers must not coerce authors into citing the reviewer's own publications to boost citation counts, and must decline to review when a conflict of interest exists.

Editorial Responsibilities and Publishing Commitments

  • Editorial independence: the editorial office makes acceptance and rejection decisions solely on the basis of a manuscript's scholarly quality, scientific value and fit with the journal, free from the influence of commercial sponsorship, advertising or external administrative pressure.
  • Protection of double-blind anonymity: the editorial office applies the highest level of technical separation and access control between reviewer information and non-anonymized author information, and firmly upholds the confidentiality of double-blind review.
  • Scholarly debate and reader feedback: we encourage scholarly debate and discussion. When readers or the academic community raise reasonable scholarly concerns about a published article, the editorial office will actively arrange for the authors to respond and for open discussion.

Misconduct Investigations, Corrections and Retractions

Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing takes a zero-tolerance approach to academic misconduct:

  • Initiating an investigation: upon receiving a named complaint or other credible information concerning plagiarism, data fabrication, ghostwriting or authorship disputes, the editorial office will establish an independent investigation panel and follow the COPE standard workflow.
  • Erratum / Corrigendum: where a published article contains unintentional typographical or formatting errors, or minor errors in non-essential data, the editorial office will publish an erratum or corrigendum and mark up the electronic full text accordingly.
  • Retraction Notice: articles found upon investigation to involve serious plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, duplicate submission, fabricated peer review or serious copyright disputes will be formally retracted through a retraction notice.
  • Retraction marking: retracted articles remain permanently available on the journal website and in indexing databases, with their records and permanent CrossRef DOI links intact. The article title and every page of the PDF are clearly marked with a red [RETRACTED] watermark, and the reasons for retraction are publicly disclosed to the scholarly community.