Skip to main content
Official Portal| Double-blind Peer Review · Open Access · Crossref DOIs

Peer Review Process and Standards

All journals published by Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing operate a double-blind peer review model. Our process is grounded in academic independence, procedural fairness, objectivity and full traceability, so that every submission receives a rigorous evaluation of its scholarly quality.

Review Model and Guiding Principles

Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing is committed to the principles of scholarly rigor, quality first, and procedural fairness. All journals published by us operate a strict double-blind peer review model.

In double-blind review, the identities of reviewers and authors are concealed from each other. This minimizes disciplinary bias, deference to established authority, personal relationships and geographic or institutional favoritism, so that every submission is assessed rigorously, objectively and fairly under the same conditions.

Review Stages and Timelines

Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing follows a standardized, digital and transparent review workflow comprising five key stages:

1. Formal Check and Technical Screening (1-3 working days)

  • Research integrity screening: the handling editor checks each manuscript for plagiarism and other misconduct using similarity-detection software. Manuscripts whose overall text similarity exceeds the warning threshold are returned directly.
  • Scope and format verification: editors check that the manuscript falls within the journal's scope and meets formatting requirements, and in particular that the main text has been fully anonymized, with author names, affiliations, grant numbers and any other information that could reveal authors' identities removed.

2. Double-Blind Expert Review (14-21 working days)

  • Reviewer selection: the handling editor selects at least two independent reviewers with deep expertise in the relevant field from the reviewer pool.
  • In-depth evaluation: reviewers provide detailed written reports based on the review criteria, assessing originality, soundness of argumentation, methodological rigor, completeness of the literature and other dimensions.

3. Consolidation of Reviews and Editorial Decision (3-5 working days)

  • The handling editor consolidates and verifies the reviewers' comments and submits a recommendation report to the Editor-in-Chief.
  • Based on the reviews, the Editor-in-Chief or the editorial office reaches one of four decisions:
  • Accept: the manuscript is of very high quality and can proceed to publication with no changes or only minor copyediting.
  • Minor Revision: the main arguments and methods are sound, but further detail, improved figures and tables, or clearer wording are needed.
  • Major Revision: the manuscript has potential for publication, but the argumentation, supporting data or theoretical depth is clearly insufficient. Authors must revise substantially, and the revised manuscript is returned to the original reviewers.
  • Reject: the manuscript lacks sufficient originality, has fundamental methodological flaws, or does not fit the aims and scope of the journal.

4. Revision and Re-review (7-14 working days)

  • After receiving the review comments, authors must submit the revised manuscript within the time limit set by the system, together with a detailed point-by-point Response to Reviewers.
  • The handling editor sends the revised manuscript back to the original reviewers for re-evaluation.

5. Final Decision by the Editor-in-Chief and Online First Publication (3-5 working days)

  • Manuscripts that pass re-review are submitted to the Editor-in-Chief for the final decision.
  • Once a manuscript is accepted, the system automatically sends an acceptance notice and the electronic publishing agreement. After the agreement is signed, the article moves on to digital typesetting and proofreading and is published Online First.

Core Criteria for Reviewers

Truth-Seeking Academic Publishing expects reviewers to uphold the highest scientific standards and to evaluate each manuscript independently against the following criteria:

  • Originality: whether the topic addresses the research frontier and offers new perspectives, methods, findings or theoretical frameworks.
  • Soundness and rigor: whether the research methods are scientifically sound and compliant, and whether the evidence supports the conclusions through rigorous logic.
  • Scholarly standards and citation quality: whether the literature is cited objectively and comprehensively, and whether related work in China and abroad is accurately discussed.
  • Practical relevance and scholarly value: whether the conclusions are of substantive value to the development of the discipline, policy-making or practice.

Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest

  • Strict confidentiality: before publication, reviewers must not disclose, share or cite any content, data or key ideas of a manuscript under review in any form to any third party.
  • Conflicts of interest: if a reviewer is related to an author, has a teacher-student relationship with an author, has collaborated directly with an author, or is a direct competitor, the reviewer must decline the invitation upon receiving it, and the editorial office will select a replacement.

Author Appeals and Arbitration

Authors who have substantive scholarly objections to a rejection decision or to the review comments may, within 10 working days of receiving notification, submit a signed written appeal to the editorial office by email, accompanied by a detailed scholarly justification. The editorial office will convene an independent third-party arbitration committee to re-examine the case and will issue a written decision within 15 working days.